Not too long ago, a live action Mulan was one of my most anticipated movies to ever come out. When the trailers came, I watched them and started crying because I've never seen so many Chinese actors on a major Hollywood movie before and as a Chinese Vietnamese person, that sense of joy and the excitement that came with it was indescribable. After watching it, the heartbreak and sheer disappointment is also just as indescribable...
I really want to see Mulan 2020 as a built-from-the-ground-up adaptation of the older classic Mulan stories but it's clear that it's a haphazard Frankensteined version of the FIRST animated Disney Mulan movie, (yes there was a sequel, and yes, the 1998 film is problematic and also beloved) and a bunch of influences from Captain Marvel, Man of Steel, Rise of Skywalker, and later seasons of Game of Thrones. What worked about the '98 version was that it was an animated musical first and foremost and the story and script was made with that in mind. On paper, a live action wuxia war epic Mulan sounds amazing but in practice, nothing about it worked. Mulan 2020 could've been about a badass, but flawed girl, fighting to protect her family and country, with motifs like reflections signifying the most important moments on her journey, and some cool thematic arcs that had one person protect her father and another person lose his. Mulan 2020 is instead about a ruthless (borderline psychopathic) woman who goes on a killing spree because a bird lady threw a shuriken at her tits. It tries to recreate scenes from the '98 animated musical version by taking out the animated musical part and making every scene expository. For a live action ACTION spectacle, it does very little showing and way too much telling. It's as if, it was written by non Asian people for non Asian people to see. You'd get alcohol poisoning if you took a shot every time someone talks about how they're trying to bring honour to their family. It tells the audience things they already know. Rick Jaffa and Amanda Silver who did the rewrites for Mulan 2020 also co-wrote some of the recent Planet of the Apes movies. And I expected better.
I would love to say that I enjoyed the acting in the movie. But that would seem as forced as the love story between Mulan and that one other guy in the movie (I don't remember his name) or anyone's name for that matter -except Mulan, because her name is literally the title of the movie. Donnie Yen was in this movie. He looked really bored and didn't do much of anything. Jet Li was also somehow in this movie as well. Liu Yifei (who's very problematic as a person) was really stiff and dull and was only really good with her physicality and stunts. The stunt work in the movie was generally good from what I can tell -but more on that later. Gong Li was the only actor who was decent in the movie (she's the bird witch lady) but she had a lot of material to work with (even though her character motivation was a complete disaster). It's also super weird and unnatural to have Chinese actors speaking in different Chinese and Chinese-English accents. This problem is similar to how Aladdin is this weird interpretation of exotic Middle Eastern culture through the eyes of White people and, in a lot of ways, Mulan is a weird pastiche of what a non Chinese person would think Chinese culture would be like. According to some Chinese viewers, the accents, costumes, and art direction were all from different parts of China and from different time periods that were centuries or maybe a millennia apart. Mulan's low class village somehow looks very rich and there's not much of a distinction between low and high class culture except for how big the buildings are. I also can't tell where anything is set in geographically speaking and that's a mix of bad green screen, terrible editing, and lack of clear establishing shots.
Since it's an action movie, there's action. It's not good action, though. Or maybe it is? I can't tell because of how miserable it was for me to track what was happening while trying to ignore some of its below average vfx and quick cuts. If you ever wanna see some weird editing and jump cuts, this movie has that for days! It manages to somehow get too much coverage and not enough, and every shot they got had to be used for some reason. Proper editing is motivated and/or invisible. The editing in Mulan (credited to David Coulson) is neither and they had no idea what they were doing. I don't like calling out specific people and that felt gross. But when it's this bad, I have to call it as it is. There are a lot of very obvious shots that were ripped directly from Game of Thrones episodes like "Battle of the Bastards" and "The Iron Throne". Clearly it's a movie for Game of Thrones fans and not for kids or wuxia fans. It's a movie that's inspired by Chinese fantasy martial arts cinema, yet it barely borrows anything from actual Chinese cinema. I would've love to see a normal strong woman fight and defeat a magical witch lady or even two magical girls engaged in a live action equivalent of a shonen anime Qi battle just for the power fantasy aspect of it. Mulan doesn't seem to work up to her powers or abilities at all. In fact, she becomes great because she was born with great super hero powers. SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS, there's no catharsis for anything that Mulan ever does and the one character that would truly pose as a challenge for her is the witch lady. She actually likes Mulan and ends up sacrificing herself, so in the end, you're just literally watching a Jedi fight a normal evil dude with nothing at stake. Mulan doesn't even suffer any physical or emotion wounds from this entire movie. She's literally Rey Palpatine to the point where someone in the movie asks Mulan what her name was and the movie does this dramatic pause and cuts. When your main character is emotionless, with zero flaws, overpowered, literally indestructible, and isn't pushed to their absolute limits by their antagonist(s) or the forces that be, it means that your main character and story are BAD.
Mulan 2020. It's bad. I don't actively seek out and or watch a lot of bad movies but this was a really bad movie. If you're out there and you like Mulan 2020, please tell me why because I really want to know and see where you're coming from. But as things stand for me personally, at this very moment, right after watching it, Mulan 2020 is the worst and most disappointing movie of 2020 and... Possibly the worst movie. Full stop. I think Mulan 2020 is actually the worst movie I've ever seen... I don't want to say that lightly. It's down there with Fant4stic, Fifty Shades of Grey, and X-Men Origins Wolverine, but I wasn't actually excited to see any of those. 2020 Mulan is a monkey's paw nightmare wish come true and it's a movie that actually broke my heart and made me lose a little bit of hope in my life in general.
PS Mulan was partially filmed in Xinjiang. Along with Liu Yifei's remarks on her support of Hong Kong police and her non-response to those criticisms, the boycotts are very much justified. You can watch and enjoy a movie all you want but please consider that in the end, along with supporting a piece of entertainment and the hard working people who worked on it, you're also supporting a corporation that's basically working with a place that puts innocent people in prison camps. These camps brainwash brutalize large and undetermined amounts of people. These are places that believe that they need to imprison people before they commit crimes. They're put in prison camps and are forced to act, think and feel. This is not okay. For a company that seemingly supports diversity and different cultures, filming in Xinjiang completely contradict those values. Disney should be ashamed of themselves. These are all major and valid issues outside of a simple piece of entertainment and needed to be addressed. It's good to see diverse faces on a major Western movie but at the same time, Mulan 2020 should not be praised for its abysmal attempt at making a Chinese movie. It's not one and it's beyond problematic to market and disguised itself as one.